Honeyfund vs The Knot Registries Compared
Honeyfund vs The Knot Registries Compared
TL;DR Verdict
Honeyfund gives you more flexibility, control, and lower effective cost for cash/honeymoon gifts, thanks to fee-free redemption paths and transparent payout choices. The Knot is a strong all-in-one registry with a wide store integration, but its cash fund model includes a 2.5% card transaction fee (paid by guests) and has fixed payout timing.
Sign Up for Honeyfund
Side-by-Side: Honeyfund and The Knot Compared
| Feature | Honeyfund | The Knot |
|---|---|---|
| Platform / Setup Fee | $0 | $0 |
| Cash / Honeymoon Fund Processing Fee | 0% (for fee-free paths); PayPal/Venmo: 2.2%; Bank: 3.9% + $0.59 | 2.5% credit card transaction fee charged to the guest |
| Who pays the fee | If you choose fast / bank transfers, you absorb third-party cost; fee-free paths let you avoid extra costs | Guests pay the 2.5% fee at checkout |
| Payout / Transfer Time | Instant prepaid / gift cards; 1 business day (PayPal/Venmo); 2-5 days (bank) | Up to 5 business days for deposits into your bank account |
| Registry Integration | Cash/gift/card paths; more control over how you redeem. Linked external registries are also available | Full registry that supports both physical items, cash funds, and linked external registries |
| Flexibility in Gift Types | Primarily cash/experiential/cards | You can mix physical gifts, cash funds, and experiences in one place |
Guest / Donor Flow & Experience
The Knot Guest Flow (Cash Fund):
- Guests visits your registry site on The Knot
- Chooses a cash fund (or item) to contribute
- If paying via credit card, a 2.5% transaction fee is added at checkout
- Guest completes payment
- The Knot deposits funds into your bank up to 5 business days later
Honeyfund Guest Flow:
- Guest gives a gift via your Honeyfund registry
- Gift enters either the couple's bank account or Honeyfund Wallet based on account setup
- Couple chooses redemption method (Honeyfund Wallet - prepaid card, gift cards, PayPal, or Venmo)
- Couple chooses how to redeem (if Honeyfund Wallet is chosen - PayPal, Venmo, Prepaid Honeyfund Mastercard, or gift cards
- Payout timing depends on the chosen method (1 business day (PayPal/Venmo), 2-5 days (bank), Instant (prepaid card/gift card)
FAQs
Q: What's the main difference between Honeyfund and The Knot?
A: Honeyfund is focused on helping couples keep more of their cash gifts by offering fee-free payout options and full control over how you use funds. The Knot adds a 2.5% credit card transaction fee to cash gifts (paid by your guests), and funds take longer to reach your account.
Q: Who pays fees on The Knot vs Honeyfund?
A: On The Knot, your guests pay the 2.5% fee automatically added to all cash gift checkouts. With Honeyfund, you choose how to receive funds, some methods have zero fees, and any third-party fees are clearly shown before payout.
Q: Is The Knot better for physical gifts than Honeyfund?
A: Yes. The Knot has a broad integrated registry that includes store products and linked registries. Honeyfund focuses on cash, honeymoon, and gift card-based gifting, with no physical product listings. However, you can link other store registries (e.g. Target, Amazon) to your Honeyfund page.
Q: Which platform gets me cash faster, The Knot or Honeyfund?
A: Honeyfund offers faster access: Instant for gift card or prepaid card redemptions, 1 day for PayPal/Venmo, and 2-5 days for bank. The Knot takes up to 5 business days for cash transfers to your bank.
Q: Can I switch from The Knot to Honeyfund easily?
A: Yes! You can export your guest list and share your new Honeyfund link. Many couples switch to avoid guest fees or gain more control over how their gifts are used.
Sign Up for Honeyfund